Instructional design: The art of lesson planning

June 27, 2022Darri Stephens

Lesson planning — it truly is the artistry of teaching. Often lesson plans are downgraded to mere outlines of planned activities, but when instructional design is folded in, they become the source of truth for crafting engaging learning experiences in the classroom. There are many different templates or models for lesson planning, with elements that may differ depending on philosophical approach or school-wide adopted techniques. Yet before diving into mapping out a lesson, you may want a refresher on sound instructional design strategies.

What is instructional design?

Instructional design goes far beyond the mere production of lesson planning or its accompanying teaching aids. Instructional design includes the goals for student learning and the methodology for achieving such goals, all while keeping in mind how individuals best engage in their learning journey. While teaching as a discipline is founded in science, its magic is in the artistry that educators add. As author and educator Mark Van Doren said, “The art of teaching is the art of assisting discovery.”

Yet as with any artistic venture, there is no hard and fast template for creating really engaging experiences. When it comes to the classroom, we have some tried and true models based on theory, research, and practice, but the best teachers add their own flavoring to such classroom recipes in order to transform learning experiences for each and every student. Instructional design is no small task, but this is the beauty and challenge for educators on a daily basis.

Lesson planning 101

1. Backward design

When it comes to instructional design, many teachers are tempted to jump into a fun activity that they saw in action or read about; there’s loads of inspiration posted daily from our “educelebs” in the blogging and social media worlds. However, according to researchers Wiggins and McTighe, it is best to start with a backward design. Backward design is a fundamental concept in instructional design.

Stages of backward design graphic

In their book, Understanding by Design, Wiggins and McTight outline that backward design consists of three sequential stages. First, you must set your overall learning goals and identify the desired results of your instruction; eyes are on the end goals. Then, you work backward to determine what evidence you will want to see to know that these goals have been met. Only lastly should you plan and craft the learning activity or experience. In traditional lesson planning, it can be hard to rein in the creativity and enthusiasm around a good idea.

Likewise, often thinking about an assessment comes at the end of lesson planning, a final step. However, by keeping the end in sight first, kids will be more engaged and their knowledge becomes more transferable. Your systematic approach to and sequence of scaffolded lesson plans will yield better student outcomes.

Once you have results in mind, Nearpod can be utilized within your lesson design by leveraging the Nearpod reports as part of acceptable evidence and then drilling down into some of the interactive features and activities such as Draw It or Drag & Drop to support the lesson’s overall learning goals and objectives. Also, consider how to use Nearpod when designing units. The corresponding lessons can be curated, organized, and housed within a lesson library.

2. Assessment

Speaking of goal setting and “acceptable evidence,” it is helpful to have a refresher on the types of assessments to continually weave into your lesson planning for daily instruction. While there are many ways to break down assessments, four common types are Diagnostic, Formative, Interim, and Summative.

Diagnostic Assessments

Consider how you can use diagnostic assessments to better understand where your students are starting — a snapshot or baseline if you will.

  • What prior knowledge do they have (from school or home)?
  • What is the breakdown of understanding amongst your whole class?
  • How does the data inform my planning?

Formative Assessments

Nearpod Open Ended Question example

Weave formative assessments throughout your lesson planning — these in-the-moment checks for understanding that can inform how you need to revise your plans for the following lesson.

  • Which concepts did students grasp?
  • Where are there gaps in their understanding?
  • Which students need extra reinforcement before moving forward?
  • What adjustments do I need to make?

Interim or Benchmark Assessments

Designed for larger groups of students, like school or district-wide, interim or benchmark assessments provide insight on the group’s progress toward said goals at set intervals in a given time period.

  • What patterns are emerging?
  • Where are there significant gaps?
  • How can you shift resources to meet needs?

Summative Assessments

As its name suggests, summative assessments are more conclusive in terms of reviewing performance at the end or after learning has occurred, but remember, assessments are really a reflection on how well the subject matter was taught — not the student’s capabilities. If a summative assessment falls short of expectations, then educators should be reflecting on their methods.

  • How did it go overall?
  • Were goals met?
  • How does this data guide next steps?

Other types of evaluation that are often referenced fall into the categories of norm-referenced and criterion-referenced assessments. However, these are another nut to crack in another article due to the politicized nature of such standardized testing.

With Nearpod, you can use the Quiz feature to check for student understanding. Also, you can get a sense of the whole group’s understanding using a Poll. Additional interactive assessment tools you could use are Matching Pairs and Drag & Drop, or add a bit of competition with Time to Climb. Consider also weaving in open-ended techniques during assessments with activities like Draw It or Open-Ended Questions. Find many pre-existing assessment ideas in Nearpod’s activity banks. Reports allows access to real-time student data that can be analyzed.

3. Student learning objectives

Depending on how educational institutions are structured, standards are designed to help set expectations about what students should know and by when. However, standards can vary based on philosophies as well as literal location. But standards can be a guiding force in lesson planning when setting goals and designing assessments. Then you, as the teacher, can craft the more practical student learning objectives at the lesson level.

SWBAT Model

Lesson objectives slide on Nearpod's Growth Mindset lesson

So with standards in mind, goals articulated, and assessments top of mind, now it is time to articulate the lesson-based evidence you are looking for. We call these practical statements student learning objectives or student learning outcomes. One common student-centered way to frame them is the SWBAT model: Students will be able to …

Following this phrase, you then can bullet a handful of concrete objectives for your students when lesson planning. But the catch is that the learning objectives need to be SMART: Specific, Measurable, Actionable, Results-oriented, and Time-bound. With such detail, learning objectives can help guide both the teacher’s instruction and the student’s learning.

Bloom’s Taxonomy

One way to hone and tweak learning objectives to make them stronger is to incorporate Bloom’s Taxonomy, which provides a framework for encouraging higher-order thinking. Bloom’s Taxonomy emphasizes a hierarchy of skills and levels of mastery that can be tied to action verbs. Take a moment to reflect on the difference between these two learning objectives:

  • EXAMPLE 1: Students will be able to understand figurative language.
  • EXAMPLE 2: Students will be able to identify two examples of figurative language within Langston Hughes’ poem, What happens to a dream deferred?, by the end of class.

Notice how the specificity of example 2 comes in with the strong action verb, the quantifiable measurement, and the timeframe? Revised learning objectives means no gray areas! Take a couple of your own learning objectives or pull some from shared lesson plans. Dissect them a bit to evaluate their efficacy. Are they framed as SMART learning objectives? Can you revise them to be stronger, SMARTer learning objectives?

Nearpod lesson library


To see how others tackle student learning objectives (and then align with rich activities), filter through Nearpod’s Lesson Library of thousands of K-12 lessons using the standards-based search function.  Don’t forget that you can then save any existing lesson and then modify it to meet your students’ needs. Change the wording, add in new content, media, or resources, plus enhance with more Nearpod interactive activities.

4. Lesson design

These learning objectives often appear at the top of lesson plans. There are many designs or models of lesson plans, and preference comes down to the educational philosophies that you (or your district) believe in.

Madeline Hunter Model of Mastery Learning

One common, time-tested format that you can ground yourself in and then modify as needed is The Madeline Hunter Model of Mastery Learning, sometimes referred to as the direct instruction model. Dr. Hunter believed that all lesson plans should encompass seven elements:

  1. 1. Objectives/standards
  2. 2. Anticipatory Set
  3. 3. Input/Modeling
  4. 4. Checks for Understanding
  5. 5. Guided Practice
  6. 6. Independent Practice* 
  7. 7. Closure*

*Can sometimes be interchanged

Anticipatory Set

Many have shifted these elements or called them by another name. For instance, you may use an anticipatory set or call it a warm-up activity, a sponge, or a connection to prior knowledge — but all of these concepts are designed to hook and focus the students’ attention and give them autonomy to consider what they already know about a given subject and what else they may want to learn about it. Similarly, some reframe the idea of modeling or direct instruction, guided practice, and independent practice into the Gradual Release of Responsibility (GRR) Model of I DO, WE DO, YOU DO to incite learner independence.

Explore and evaluate how other educators design their lesson plans and consider adopting the model to a template that works best for you (and your district) to engage students the most! Also, do consider how you can add reflection notes at the bottom of your lesson plans year over year as to what worked well and not so well. This reflective practice will make your lesson planning an iterative process based on your students’ needs, not your planbook.

Nearpod Slide Editor walkthrough

In addition to viewing Nearpod’s library as an ideas bank, where you can modify and customize existing lessons for your classroom, you can create your own content slides on Nearpod. As a start, each slide could address one of the seven elements of a lesson plan. Remember that you can organize these lessons into folders to share with an administrator for lesson review or with colleagues when team teaching.

5. Edtech adoption

Last but not least, thoughtful edtech adoption really does make your job easier if your goal is maximizing your time to engage students to own their own learning journey. However, using technology for teaching and learning is much different than using technology in our everyday lives.

SAMR

Dr. Ruben Puentedura has shared his popular SAMR model, which is a framework that we can use to evaluate the purpose of using educational technologies. Too often, devices and tools are mere substitutions for age-old practices. And while substitution can be a first step, we should be thinking about edtech as an integral part of our instructional design. He suggests challenging ourselves to move from mere enhancement through Substitution and Augmentation to transformation through Modification and Redefinition.

  • Substitution: Does the task require technology? How might it be enhanced with technology?
  • Augmentation: How might technology be an essential component of this task? How is the task improved?
  • Modification: How might the technology transform the learning experience? How is the task significantly changed?
  • Redefinition: How can the technology allow for creation of new tasks or opportunities? How are the learning goals redefined to something that wasn’t possible before?

TPACK

Another model that is helpful schoolwide and across teaching teams is TPACK. TPACK encourages us as educators to think of where the intersections of our expertise lie, and how we might focus on fortifying the less strong areas through thoughtful professional development as well as collaboration. TPACK focuses on three, complex, intersecting kinds of knowledge: Technological, Pedagogical, and Content Knowledge. This visual model shows the resulting seven areas, with the epicenter being a melding of all — TPACK. Many educators feel confident about their pedagogical and content experience and experiences, but less so around the technological. With such introspection, schools can set meaningful professional growth opportunities for the coming school year that will aid in enhancing all instructional design efforts. Technology no longer becomes just an add-on, a reward, or a thorn in our sides; it becomes an essential element of today’s teaching and learning.

Multiple solutions in 1 with Nearpod slide graphic

Teachers and students alike can leverage the creation side of Nearpod, serving a myriad of needs through multimedia integrations, interactive activities, and formative assessment tools. If you’re searching for an edtech tool to create lessons to share with students, Nearpod offers all of these solutions in one place.

Now it’s time create your lesson plan

Instructional design and lesson planning really is a craft, one that deserves to be revisited and revised year over year as new methodologies and trends emerge. When lesson planning, take a moment to reflect on your own philosophies and how those align with your school’s. Consider how each lesson can address and meet the diversity of needs found in your classroom. Ask yourself how your pedagogy is based on sound research, yet is uniquely yours. And continue to be that lifelong learner that we all as educators hope to be cultivating in our students.

Interested in reading more about this topic? Check out this blog post: 22 Tips I wish I’d known as a first year teacher

Prev Post Next Post